(Possibly) Working aGPS Solution! (Take Two)

[PearlMikeJam]

I installed the HTC Quick GPS and went to lunch to play with it. It got a lock within about 20 seconds, which was impressive, however it put me out in the middle of the ocean (as others have experienced) using GMaps. This has never happened to me and it did not correct itself after more than 10 minutes. After doing a soft reset, I could not get any lock, attempting for about 30 minutes. I removed it and did a soft reset and got a lock using the old GPS Quick Position in about 30 seconds and it located me accurately.

Are you folks doing anything special to get yours working and is it an improvement over what Adryn already had?

As a side note, I am running Adryn's 4.0.1 Vanilla 6.5 ROM.

[yojoe600]

it seems to do that sometimes... all i do is re download with gps sats and it seems to fix it

[false_apology]

Well, here is my experience today. I downloaded the file using HTCQGps, and headed off to lunch. Right as I left the office I started gMaps. After about 6 minutes of driving, I got the "Weak GPS Signal error". I was a bit discouraged. I parked, exited my car, and re-opened GMaps. GMaps then got a lock in 20 seconds. So I'm not sure if it had to do with me moving or my position, but it could not lock onto to me until I was stationary. After that it did get a fast lock (20 seconds, and this was a cold lock. I had not used my GPS in over 24 hours and had traveled aprox 60 miles).

This does seem to get faster locks; not a placebo effect.

[syrguy1969]

I have been playing with it a bit as well, and I haven't had a lock yet (storming here though), but I did notice in the settings 'auto update when data is expired' is checked. Obviously none of us has ran this for a week yet to see if it does, but has anyone had any experience or know of anyone using this that knows if/how the auto updating works?

If it does work the way it indicated, this may be THE app for what we need!!!!

[yojoe600]

u have to not be moving to get a lock

[jaewon223]

ok after extensive use i've come to the conclusion that quick gps does in fact work, with a caveat. i'm not exactly sure what the variable is, i'm assuming weather does in fact play a larger role than suspected, nevertheless, there are times when i can get a lock in 10-30 seconds and other attempts the time is similar to a cold lock (3-6 min.) i've tested while walking on a clear day, driving on a clear day, under cloudy conditions, etc.

so final verdict: better than not using it. :T

[PearlMikeJam]

with everyone seeming to have success with the HTC Quick GPS, I will have to give it another try.

All those who are using the app, has anyone updated the file over wifi? I get no signal in my office, so I updated the sats over wifi. Do I need to update over the cellular line to better determine location?

[JustinAppi]

Earlier today, I indicated that I couldn't get a lock at all. We were having thunderstorms going by all late morning and early afternoon. Since they've p*****, I've consistently gotten a lock sitting in my living room (a single family home) in less than a minute. Outside in less than 30 seconds. Looks good to me. Thanks AD

[adam2dot0]

HOLY MONKEY! I installed Adryn's modded HTC Quick GPS...INSTANT GPS lock in TomTom7. No placebo effect there, it used to take 2 minutes or more. Thanks Adryn! "WE'RE NOT WORTHY! WE'RE NOT WORTHY! WE'RE SCUM! WE SUCK!"

[Doc007]

Great software idea!! =D> I have yet to try it but I can see how this would work. This reminds me of an old convo I had with a fellow member a while back. Perhaps you might be able to implement some of my ideas into your software to help people get a quick lock in a new location that hasn't already been cached. (Old convo is posted below for your convenience. I know its long but I hope you will find it interesting as I did.)

Originally Posted by sofladavid

Also. a tip for those having trouble with GPS.

The way GPS works, it that the receiver has to get a "fix" on where you are by receiving signals from at least three satellites. The sattelites are scattered through the sky all around the earth. Obstructions such as Buildings, trees, Roofs, etc will block the signal from being received by the GPS receiver Think about how weak these signals are that are traveling all the way from a satellite in outer space.

When you first turn the GPS on, it hunts around trying to find at least ONE satellite. At that point, the unit has no idea where you are, or what time it is, so it has no idea what sattelite it should be looking for , or where. It's purely trial and error, until it comes across one sattelite that it can communicate with. Once it finds one, it has to download what is called an "almanac". The almanac tells the GPS receiver which other sattelites are in the area and should therefore be listening for. The process of downloading this almanac takes about a minute. If you turn a corner, go under a tree, or otherwise interrupt the downloading of the almanac, the process has to start all over again. luckly, while the almanac is downloading, the GPS is still looking for other satellites and if it finds another one, it starts downloading the almanac from that satellite also. Once it has succesfully downloaded the almanac, then it uses that info to find the other sattelites in the area and determine your location based on the signals it is receiving from the different satellites based on the almanac. The almanac is kept up to date while the GPS is on and connected to the satellites.

If you turn the unit off and then back on a short time later, and you are still in the same general location, then the unit remembers the almanac and knows which sattelites to listen to so it can calculate your position very quickly. But, if it has been a while sine the unit was turned off, or you have moved substantially since the last signals were received, then the almanac is outdated and the unit has to download the alamanac again from scratch (longer time to getting a GPS fix)

This is a very leymans explanation, and I'm sure there may be a few discrepancies (or oversimplifications), but it may help some to understand why sometimes it takes a while to get a GPS fix.

Also, Googlemaps does not give alot of feedback as to what is going on in the background. all you see on the screen is "seeking....."

Most of the handheld GPS units (the GPS apps I am testing too) have a "satellite screen" which shows you what satellites the unit can see, and if they are in "acquisition mode" (downloading the almanac)

Pardon the typos. This is too long to proofread

Originally Posted by Doc007

Thanks for the interesting read on GPS fixing. Maybe you can help me answer my questions based on your tutorial...

Why not have a program calculate the location of the satellites based on user input of a cross street (if you are on a road) or a time + city/town (if you are hiking)?

I figure since these satellites orbit the earth at calculated speed along with the earths rotation. Why not have a program which can make a temporary almanac/offline almanac until a true/real almanac can be downloaded from the primary and/or secondary satellites? Wouldn't something like this reduce the amount of trial and error? Which would result in a reduced acquisition time?

Originally Posted by tgreenstein

You're right. Actually, some routing software and GPSr allow you to input a "known" latitude and longitude (or sometimes a city name) from which it starts the process of searching for satellites based on what's called an ephemeris (a fancy name for a table that lists the projected locations of all of the GPS). My Garmin Nuvi 660 does this and some of the standalone PPC software does as well.

Back in the "early" days of consumer GPSr use this was fairly common as the "time to acquisition" of these devices was pretty slow -- 10-20 minutes wasn't uncommon. Current devices can usually obtain a fix in far less time and, probably as a result, don't offer the option to input a "known" location to serve as a starting point.

Originally Posted by Doc007

Thanks for your response.

Would you happen to know which older and/or current PPC softwares utilize ephemeris? I would be interested in trying something like this out in my area where it can take up to 5-6 minutes to aquire a fix from a cold start. The aquisition time is significantly increased while moving. (Likely due to downloading partial almanacs)

I would be interested in seeing if there is a significant difference in aquisition time by using ephemeris in my neighborhood.