LG Fathom, LG Ally or what?

[aczlan]

I am looking to upgrade phones. I am on Verizon and will not be leaving (coverage+lots of family on VZW).
I had an XV6700 in the past and loved it. I had WM6.0 installed on it and it worked great. Sadly, it decided to stop charging and I cant seem to get that fixed (hints on fixing it would be useful, otherwise I am going to sell it on ebay for parts).
I am currently using a Palm Treo 755P and it is ok. I like the battery life and sound quality, but would like a wider screen, a newer OS and something with a slide out keyboard. I will be buying this phone on ebay as I don't have ANY interest in paying for a data plan.

My phone capability requirements are:

• Decent call quality
• Touchscreen
• Slideout QWERTY keyboard
• WiFi (able to connect to a WPA2 network)
• Decent battery life (charging every other day unless used heavily)
• Bluetooth
• Edit docs
• Read PDFs
• Install apps
• Sync pictures and docs with my Windows 7 desktop
• Decent camera
• Able to take a 4GB+ card of some sort
• Price: $150ish in ebay
• NOT Windows Mobile 7

Looks aren't really important to me, but durability is a plus.

From what I have found, I like the Fathom and the Ally, but I am wondering if there is anything that sets one of these phones ahead of the other and if there are any other phones that I should add to my "watch for" list?

Thanks in advance for the advice and opinions.

Aaron Z