Explanation of memory usage in an AUK update

[Rally1]

My understanding (I am ready to be corrected) is that you can't tell in File Explorer. Think of program memory like RAM on your PC. The more apps you have actively running the more program memory is used. You can tell under the memory app in Settings, or in 3rd party monitors.

It uses less storage memory because there is a 63M chunk alloted to the ROM. So even if you only have 50M in the ROM, all 63M is allocated. If it's not in the ROM it would have to be installed on the left over 3*M.

Must be nice to have a PPC with 256M+ and not have to worry.

[nuguy]

Originally Posted by TambourineMan

When one looks at a directory of files using file explorer, how does one tell if the file is in program memory or storage memory?

Why does including a program in a ROM to be flashed use less storage memory than if it were later installed in device program memory?

In Total Commander chose 'show' then select 'hide files in rom' - this, of course, will show you the files that are NOT in ROM (Read Only Memory).

[TambourineMan]

But storage memory must be like RAM in a PC too. As I open programs and and run them and do not close them or clear their caches, storage memory also goes down

[colonel]

TamboourineMan, think of it this way....

Program Memory is the RAM of a PC. Remember, this is on a seperate chip in the PPC.

The 63MB ROM partition would be a locked partition on the PC

Storage Memory is the usable partition for the end user (drive :c on the PC). Here the user can install apps and store documents, files, etc.

The Extended Rom would be drive :d on some PCs where the manufacturer apps and backups are stored. It is just another usable partition that was designed for a certain purpose but can be unlocked and used by the end user.

[helmi_c]

Originally Posted by Big D5

I agree and if you will read all of the post you quoted found HERE and this post HERE you will find that is exactly what I said. If you could kindly link me to the AKU's you tested that have 40 mb free I would appreciate it I would like to compare so I can make my update better.

This is for ilustrating only...

This is the big fat size APP in My Broadcomm Version R3 Junkholic ROM Variant Contains.

Adobe Reader 1.93mb
Additional Ringtones 704kb
BroadComm Stack 7mb
Calysta Dictionary 2.39mb
Flash 7 1.38mb Not activated
Icon Customize 367kb
SPB Plus 2.08mb
SPB Backup 1.09mb
TCPMP 0.81 2.65mb
Task Manager 1.6 203kb
PIE Plus 577kb
Resco 2007 1.37mb
Remote Desktop Mobile 738kb
Jeyo SMS Backup 340kb
MS Voice Command 3.98mb Not activated
Mobibook Reader 1.7mb
New CommManager v.1.6.3(Black) 964kb
NET CF 2 SP2 5.30mb
Windows Live 1.75mb


File copied to Storage Memory By OEM (Initflashfiles.dat) after flash.
SPB plus 377kb
MMS Old Version (3.0.6.24) 556kb
-----
Total copied files 933kb

Free Storage Memory After Flash 40.73mb
Program Memory 30.31mb (With Broadcomm Stack ON, SPB Plus Active)


If eliminated above oem (MMS & SPB) Storage Space after reset should be 40.73mb + 933kb = 41.66mb? ...

NoJunk ROM? Can someone explain to me what the point of NoJunk ROM?... wasting ur precious rom space for nothing? isn't silly? if u dont use it, u can still burn it to rom, but you just dont activated it, use cab for activated junk app... simply isnt?

Edit:
Add Activator CAB Example (MS VoiceCommander) activator size is beetwen 1-98kb in size, better then Install the whole APP (3.94mb) right?
ftp://ppcgeeks:ezupload@up.ppcgeeks....ateMsVC1.6.zip

This way U'll hv the best of both world... Or I whould like to call it a much Better Vanilla ROM...

[jbonilla]

Originally Posted by Big D5

If you could kindly link me to the AKU's you tested that have 40 mb free I would appreciate it I would like to compare so I can make my update better.

I don't have the links to the ROM's I used, but I'm pretty sure the AKU 3.3 was Helmi's first release and the AKU 3.5 was a custom ROM I did using the first AKU 3.5 kitchen. The first thing I do after flashing is write down the available Program and Storage Memory on post-it notes so I have a reference on what I've done. I wouldn't recommend using any of those kitchens anyway as they're old and the Unified Kitchen is so much more stable (for me anyway). I'm not sure the trade-off in stability would be worth the slight storage increase. Like Helmi said, his most recent release has over 40 MB storage available and even more if you remove the OEM's that create files outside the Windows folder. My main point is that your comparison shouldn't be to Kirvin's Clean and Simple as it has a few additions that take up additional storage space. Any storage comparison should be against a ROM made with Unified Kitchen with no OEM's added which could be taking up storage space.

[ran-o-matic]

Originally Posted by helmi_c

...
NoJunk ROM? Can someone explain to me what the point of NoJunk ROM?... wasting ur precious rom space for nothing? isn't silly? if u dont use it, u can still burn it to rom, but you just dont activated it, use cab for activated junk app... simply isnt?
...

Exactly! The only point I can ever come up with is stability.

[helmi_c]

Originally Posted by ran-o-matic

Exactly! The only point I can ever come up with is stability.

If the App make instability issue? dont activate it (or deactivate it), or better don't added to rom at first place...

still... I dont see the point of NoJunk is all about... why add nothing to it if we hv the space? if we dont use it? just dont activate it (it has zero effect), but the junks might usefull for others... so user hv ability to choose what app needed or not with activated method... The rom itself will be advance rom capability, but user might also make it "Standart" rom..

well Activated method is a bit complicated to the developers then add nothing to it offcourse...

[TambourineMan]

Colonel,

Thanks for the explanation - it helped

Lowly ex-Captain

[Big D5]

Originally Posted by helmi_c

If the App make instability issue? dont activate it (or deactivate it), or better don't added to rom at first place...

still... I dont see the point of NoJunk is all about... why add nothing to it if we hv the space? if we dont use it? just dont activate it (it has zero effect), but the junks might usefull for others... so user hv ability to choose what app needed or not with activated method... The rom itself will be advance rom capability, but user might also make it "Standart" rom..

well Activated method is a bit complicated to the developers then add nothing to it offcourse...

Ok you are right as usual now you have spent enough time on this subject so get back to makeing that kitchen so we can all get to cooking, Please