Which Android Phone and Why?

[imnuts]

I've been having issues recently with my TP2 and will likely get a new phone soon, within the next month. I'm getting my 4th replacement device now as all of them have had some sort of issue, and I'm getting tired of replacing my phone every few days. So, I'm wondering which of the new VZW Android phone's you would pick and why. ATM, I'm thinking of trying to get it replaced with the Incredible, but could be swayed to another device, depending on what others think. Although I have a hardware keyboard now, I rarely use it, so that's why I'm not automatically going with the Droid 2, though the physical keyboard would be a better argument for getting that as a replacement over something else.