Prefer User Customization or Tweaked ROM

[jakdillard]

Originally Posted by boggsie

Can you or would you mind elaborating on the issue that you reference in your last sentence?

I may be mistaken, but it appears to me that the issue may be related to taking a ROM (*.nbh) file, using it as a donor, decomposing it and using the components as foundation for other work.

If that is the issue, then how can or how are people supposed to reconcile this issue, with the fact that there is a sticky in the upgrades forum describing exactly how to do this very thing?

How to for Developing http://forum.ppcgeeks.com/showthread.php?t=20550

First off the tutorial is to teach people how to port an os or sys folder to a rom ie taking a kaiser sys folder and porting it to a vogue oem rom not taking OMJ and removing pimbackup and whatever and building the same rom. For that tutorial I should have mentioned that you need stock roms but I did not think that anyone would be simple and use a well put together custom as a "foundation" for another custom ?

[boggsie]

Isn't getting a donor rom, decomposing into a bare kitchen and then adding and removing spices, etc. to satisfy a particular taste, part of the justification behind publishing the Vogue_Kitchen_Tools.rar file on the ftp site?

I might happen to like the main course (OS CE version) but I don't like asparagus (TouchFlo), brussel sprouts (BioTouch) and carrots (Remote Desktop), so I am going to take them out in favor of corn (User Customization) and green beans (Voice Command) [for example].

Please continue the discussion, so that I might understand the issue that you referenced a couple of posts up.

While I am here, I expect that I can learn about more than PPCs.

Thank you, jakdillard.

Best regards,
-boggsie