Ill Take The Flaming..Help W/Case

[aw3964]

ive spent a ridiculous amount of time reading threads for a new case and i would like some current opinions. please, im trying to ask politely for anyone that will help

i've purchased Zagg's but i am not quite satisfied--not because of the quality, but becase i would like a case instead:

black, seidio-like but not the seidio price (i will pay the 30 however if it is by far the best option), not very soft rubberized but enough for the grip, no issues with the prox sensor


i have read the reviews and threads so believe i am down to

-seidio
-nakedcellphone
-blujay (out of stock?)
-bodyglove
-daydeal


are there any more that fit proper and do not have any issues? is seidio the overall consensus best pick?