Debating between phones.

[SlashX1896]

I own the Touch Pro 2 with verizon, but the board on the screen is messed up now, and its all discolored and does not work (doesnt have water damage people are thinking magnetic damage?) I was going to get a replacement and keep it as a backup phone, but i found out my plan is eligible for another upgrade, so was going to get a new phone aswell. But im debating because the Moto droid is 199, and the htc droid / eris is only 99, i wanted to go with the moto but is it worth the extra 100?
thanks, slashx