Speed on Sprint Touch Vs GSM Touch

[slypher]

OK, so i'm reading through some posts over at XDA and come across the one below:

http://forum.xda-developers.com/showthread.php?t=366314

daniel_rh
Senior Member


I wanna see how is the performance between ROMS versions (6, 6.1, cooked roms...), Touch versions (Elf, Vogue, Cruise...)

You can use this cool benchmark tool to make the test:
http://www.virtualspaghetti.com/file...k2007Setup.exe

Here are my result with and without overclocking:

HTC Touch, stock speed: 201mhz / Overclocking speed: up to 273mhz
ROM version: ShadoW_2.0 WWE
OS: 6.1 (5.2.2021 build 19521.1.1.0)

Stock speed: 1169
Overclocked: 1588

OK, so i download the application (its free) and i run it. I'm thinking, my touch is twice as fast as the GSM version, so my results should be much higher than the ones posted.

Boy was i wrong, i got the following:

HTC Vogue, stock speed: 400mhz
ROM version: Mr. JCarter's custom (Based on No2Chem Build 107)
OS: 6.1

Stock speed: 1293

What the heck is wrong with this picture..can anyone shed some light on this. Also, while we are at it, can we get some numbers on other Roms (6.1 clean, 6.1 custom, 6.0 clean, etc) to see if there is a big variance?

-s

[nobrakes]

my final score was 1463.

running sprint vogue on nochem build 100


second try final 1470

[slypher]

Originally Posted by nobrakes

my final score was 1463.

running sprint vogue on nochem build 100

WOW, my install must be hosed or something! looks like i will have to try some other WM 6.1 options.

-s

[Tenny]

Sadly the ARM11 processor was highly over-rated imo. Too busy atm to try the test but looking forward for more tests.

[bedoig]

Comparing mhz from one brand of processor to another usually leads to misleading assumptions. It would appear that the qualcomm processor isn't nearly as capable as you would think. And didn't Sprint specifically request an upgraded processor for the Touch vs the GSM version? Lends some credibility to that article about HTC and Sprint being led to believe that the processor would perform better than it does (thus leading to the poor video performance and that whole class action lawsuit business).

[dew.man]

Let's not overlook that most of the test performed with this particular app are multimedia/graphics based rather than computational so the "poor" performance could be due to the "missing driver" issue...

[Glossman]

Just tested with OMJ's latest 6.1 ROM: Scored a 1589 on the first try and 1439 on the second. The third was 1694.

I can't explain the variation, especially because I soft reset after each one.

[blue4shizzle]

my question is how fast is the sprint touch before you flash the custom rom?

[slypher]

Originally Posted by blue4shizzle

my question is how fast is the sprint touch before you flash the custom rom?

I was hoping that someone with the stock rom would also run the test. I think its interesting that OMJ's rom scored so high, maybe the pagepool made a difference?

-s

[slypher]

HTC Touch, stock speed: 400mhz
ROM version: Mr J Carter's Custom v2
OS: 6.1 (5.2.19199, AKU 1.0.0)
Pagepool: 20mb
ROM Base: WM6.1 Build 107
Stock speed: 1293

HTC Touch, stock speed: 400mhz
ROM version: Mr J Carter's Custom v2
OS: 6.1 (5.2.19199, AKU 1.0.0)
Pagepool: 20mb
ROM Base: WM6.1 Build 107
Stock speed: 1446

HTC Touch, stock speed: 400mhz
ROM version: Mr J Carter's Custom v2
OS: 6.1 (5.2.19199, AKU 1.0.0)
Pagepool: 32mb
ROM Base: WM6.1 Build 107
Stock speed: 1456

HTC Touch, stock speed: 400mhz
ROM version: Mr J Carter's Custom v2
OS: 6.1 (5.2.19199, AKU 1.0.0)
Pagepool: 32mb
ROM Base: WM6.1 Build 107
Stock speed: 1541

HTC Touch, stock speed: 400mhz
ROM version: OMJ v5
OS: 6.1 CE OS 5.2.19716 BUILD 19716.1.0.0 No2
Pagepool: 32mb
ROM Base: WM6.1 Build 107
Stock speed: 1465

HTC Touch, stock speed: 400mhz
ROM version: OMJ v5
OS: 6.1 CE OS 5.2.19716 BUILD 19716.1.0.0 No2
Pagepool: 32mb
ROM Base: WM6.1 Build 107
Stock speed: 1462

HTC Touch, stock speed: 400mhz
ROM version: OMJ v5
OS: 6.1 CE OS 5.2.19716 BUILD 19716.1.0.0 No2
Pagepool: 32mb
ROM Base: WM6.1 Build 107
Stock speed: 1459

HTC Touch, stock speed: 400mhz
ROM version: Derek's v9
OS: 6.1 (5.2.1620)
Pagepool: 24mb
ROM Base: Unknown
Stock speed: 1473

HTC Touch, stock speed: 400mhz
ROM version: Derek's v9
OS: 6.1 (5.2.1620)
Pagepool: 24mb
ROM Base: Unknown
Stock speed: 1399

HTC Touch, stock speed: 400mhz
ROM version: Derek's v9
OS: 6.1 (5.2.1620)
Pagepool: 24mb
ROM Base: Unknown
Stock speed: 1513

HTC Touch, stock speed: 400mhz
ROM version: Mr Geoff v3
OS: 6.1 (5.2.19199)
Pagepool: 32mb
ROM Base: WM6.1 Build 107
Stock speed: 1431

HTC Touch, stock speed: 400mhz
ROM version: Mr Geoff v3
OS: 6.1 (5.2.19199)
Pagepool: 32mb
ROM Base: WM6.1 Build 107
Stock speed: 1344

HTC Touch, stock speed: 400mhz
ROM version: Sprint OEM
OS: 6.0
Pagepool: 12mb?
Stock speed: 1471

HTC Touch, stock speed: 400mhz
ROM version: Sprint OEM
OS: 6.0
Pagepool: 12mb?
Stock speed: 1472

HTC Touch, stock speed: 400mhz
ROM version: Sprint Oem
OS: 6.0
Pagepool: 12mb?
Stock speed: 1471

HTC Touch, stock speed: 400mhz
ROM version: Sprint Oem
OS: 6.0
Pagepool: 32mb
Stock speed: 1522

HTC Touch, stock speed: 400mhz
ROM version: Sprint Oem
OS: 6.0
Pagepool: 32mb
Stock speed: 1516

HTC Touch, stock speed: 400mhz
ROM version: Sprint Oem
OS: 6.0
Pagepool: 32mb
Stock speed:1498

Not much variance between the ROMS, 6.0 and 6.1 seem close. The highest numbers come from the higher page pool roms, but they are not that much higher than the Sprint OEM. The OEM also seems to have the most consistent numbers.

-s

EDIT: added 3 test results using the Sprint OEM with a 32mb page pool.

All Tests were done off of a fresh flash, nothing installed other than what is built into the ROM itself (for ROMS with User Customization I reset the phone before the custom stuff installed).

Also a soft reset was done between each test.