Remove "screen off" from End Key

[Raccroc]

I understand, I really do. It just not what I'm used to and, from a more functional viewpoint, it doesn't make as much since to me.

First and foremost, it is a phone, and that is it's most important task. To facilitate that, from my viewpoint, you basically need an "on-hook" and "off-hook" button.

What I''m used to is...
Green (off-hook) - I'd prefer this go to a dialpad, but can get used to it going to a searchable contacts list.
Red (on-hook) - End calls, and doubles as a end (or minimize in the WM world) applications.

To add any additional features to either button just complicates things, and can cause it to behave in ways I do not expect. Hitting the End Button to go to Today isn't a problem; however, it's tendency to turn off the display whether or not I'm already there is a problem (applications still opening, during open dialogs, etc.). Plus (and this may be the bigger issue), since it functionally "ends a call", I have no way to manually turn off the display off while talking. That means, I'm going to use another button to blank the screen anyway, so why have to buttons assigned to the same task? This is especially true when I'm already used to the display-off being a side button.

In the end, it's just a personal preference thing.

[skeegcpp]

Originally Posted by Raccroc

It just not what I'm used to

And there lies the issue, not the phone. C Palm is a little different then HTC.

[Raccroc]

Originally Posted by skeegcpp

And there lies the issue, not the phone. C Palm is a little different then HTC.

Never stated anything different. I am fully aware the issue is mine as it is one of habit and personal preference. That is; however, one of the main purposes in asking for a "mod" and "hacks" to a device. To make it act in ways not originally designed by the manufacturer.

[dannzeman]

Originally Posted by Raccroc

I understand, I really do. It just not what I'm used to and, from a more functional viewpoint, it doesn't make as much since to me.

First and foremost, it is a phone, and that is it's most important task. To facilitate that, from my viewpoint, you basically need an "on-hook" and "off-hook" button.

What I''m used to is...
Green (off-hook) - I'd prefer this go to a dialpad, but can get used to it going to a searchable contacts list.

I can kinda understand this point but it would silly for Palm (or any phone manufacturer) to duplicate this with only a software dialpad by using the green dial key since the device has a hardware dialpad on the front. I know you may not be used to the search feature by just typing but if you know the phone number you can just dial and hit call and it'll work just like using the software dialpad. I think thats why they added the extra "features" when you press the green dial key, to try and make it a little more useful. I put features in quotes because there are many people that don't like it. I like the way Palm has done it because it saves me the step of having to open the dialpad and then a submenu just to get to my call log and redial list. The software dialpad is just a click away though after hitting the green dial key.

Originally Posted by Raccroc

Red (on-hook) - End calls, and doubles as a end (or minimize in the WM world) applications.

To add any additional features to either button just complicates things, and can cause it to behave in ways I do not expect. Hitting the End Button to go to Today isn't a problem; however, it's tendency to turn off the display whether or not I'm already there is a problem (applications still opening, during open dialogs, etc.).

If you left the end key functionality stock it should only turn the screen off when you're at the Today screen. If your in the middle of an app or open dialog and you press the end key it should take you directly to the Today screen. I'm not sure why its turning off the display when you don't expect it to.

Originally Posted by Raccroc

Plus (and this may be the bigger issue), since it functionally "ends a call", I have no way to manually turn off the display off while talking. That means, I'm going to use another button to blank the screen anyway, so why have t[w]o buttons assigned to the same task? This is especially true when I'm already used to the display-off being a side button.

In the end, it's just a personal preference thing.

Ah, now I see what you're talking about. I guess that was the reason I was looking for when I was asking all those questions earlier. Many, many people (including myself) find it annoying that you can't turn the screen off while in a call. Its simple functionality that should be present. It hasn't really bugged me enough to do anything about it but I know I've read solutions at treocentral.com.

One thing you may keep in the back of your mind is that there is a registry hack to enable the assignment of an app to a single click of the side button in addition to pressing and holding it for 2-3 seconds. It can be found here. I assigned an app called Keylight to the side button so that then I press it once it turns the keyboard backlight on or off regardless of whether the backlight for the screen is on or off. I'm sure you could find an app that would turn the screen off and assign it to the side button's single click, that way you're not taking up the functionality of another button.

[Raccroc]

Originally Posted by dannzeman

I can kinda understand this point but it would silly for Palm (or any phone manufacturer) to duplicate this with only a software dialpad by using the green dial key since the device has a hardware dialpad on the front. I know you may not be used to the search feature by just typing but if you know the phone number you can just dial and hit call and it'll work just like using the software dialpad. I think thats why they added the extra "features" when you press the green dial key, to try and make it a little more useful. I put features in quotes because there are many people that don't like it. I like the way Palm has done it because it saves me the step of having to open the dialpad and then a submenu just to get to my call log and redial list. The software dialpad is just a click away though after hitting the green dial key.

First, I misspoke when I stated "dialpad". You are correct that the dialpad would be goofy considering you have one on the keyboard. What I meant was a "dialing screen" with a "white space" you can type in a number (while it also searches your contacts and call logs). Hitting the Dial key and then going through a menu to dialpad also sucks. So, I've modified the phone so that the Green phone button goes directly to the dialing screen.
Now I just need to figure out how to get it to stop searching the contact from the Today screen on keyboard press...The dialing/contact search from the Today screen is, personally, the single worse "feature" they've added to the phones. It is just to easy to accidentally hit a key on the keyboard, while say, the phone is in my pocket, and dialing from the Today screen is an annoyance which saves me the "extra effort" of hitting just one large convenience key on my phone before dialing a number is just not at all worthwhile. Personal preference.

Originally Posted by dannzeman

If you left the end key functionality stock it should only turn the screen off when you're at the Today screen. If your in the middle of an app or open dialog and you press the end key it should take you directly to the Today screen. I'm not sure why its turning off the display when you don't expect it to.

Upon further playing with is, it does seem to be the case. Mostly, it is me hitting it when I think I'm do something else....again, I'm not used to it turning off the screen, so it's habitual for me to hit it. Still, backto to my original question...I want to disable that feature.

Originally Posted by dannzeman

Ah, now I see what you're talking about. I guess that was the reason I was looking for when I was asking all those questions earlier. Many, many people (including myself) find it annoying that you can't turn the screen off while in a call. Its simple functionality that should be present. It hasn't really bugged me enough to do anything about it but I know I've read solutions at treocentral.com.

One thing you may keep in the back of your mind is that there is a registry hack to enable the assignment of an app to a single click of the side button in addition to pressing and holding it for 2-3 seconds. It can be found here. I assigned an app called Keylight to the side button so that then I press it once it turns the keyboard backlight on or off regardless of whether the backlight for the screen is on or off. I'm sure you could find an app that would turn the screen off and assign it to the side button's single click, that way you're not taking up the functionality of another button.

Thanks for the Link. I've been looking for that exact functionality. Again though...if I am going to assign the side key to turn off the display, why do I need it on the End key as well? Seems redundant.