Re: need help with recovery
 

I would say that now they are pretty much equal, for a while their aman ra was the way to go but clockworkmod finally updated their recovery to add what aman ra could do. You should be fine sticking with clockworkmod.

Re: need help with recovery
 

The jury is still out about how well the cache is cleared using clockworkmod's recovery.

Re: need help with recovery
 

Most of us here prefer AMON. Clockworks Nand backup has been failling to back up the RSA keys. It also does not wipe the Cache(s) clean.

If you are not going to flash customs Roms (that's what they all say but eventually you will) it doesn't matter much.

Re: need help with recovery
 

Clockworkmod 2.6.0.1 now backs up the wimax image and rsa keys, and the Dalvik cache seems to wipe ok. I started having a problem with aman ra doing nandroid restores so I switched back to clockworkmod and its working great. The nandroid problem started when I used Titanium Backup to move programs to SD that aren't designed to move by the developer. After that I started getting nandroid restore problems. I always asks me to install nandroid mobile-sh from adb but I don't get that error with clockwork now and since it does the RSA keys now I switched back.

Re: need help with recovery
 

Sounds like Kouch is getting it straightened out. One advantage of Clockword is its integration with Rom Manager. With Amon, the app is just a spacer!

Re: need help with recovery
 

I hadn't flashed a new rom with the new clockwork yet, but I did flash a patch.zip today using rom manager and Koush stuck a nag in the flashing process lambasting developers for not switching to the edify scripting tools whenever you flash an amend scripted rom or zip. On another note, there was a tweet by Koush today that he is going to add aman ra support into rom manager allowing full functionality of rom manager with aman ra recovery.

Re: need help with recovery
 

Im fairly new to all of this so excuse the questions...Im on HW version 004( I seen somewhere that HW versions matter, i may have misunderstood) and currently on hboot 0.97 and clockwork 2.5.0.1. i see all these threads on how it doesn't wipe things well and when i go to wipe davlik it doesn't, or so it appears, do anything like when you wipe cache...is it suppose to be like that. I dl the pc36img, is this the latest amon 2.1.1? and where can i dl the latest 2.6.0.1? Just a lil confused please advise.

Thanks in advance

Re: need help with recovery
 

I always get the willies when I read, "I dl the pc36img". Let me explain something here.
The PC36IMG.zip is a moniker that tells the HBoot to test it and install the contents after asking the user.
There is NO gurantee as to what is wrapped up with that filename. Unless you know what it is you have downloaded, open the zip file and look inside.
A ROM will be 175 to 200 mb
Recovery will be around 4 to 5 mb
A standalone radio will be 150 to 170 KB

But you can put anything on that file. What it does is circumvent the need to use recovery. Before acquiring Root, this is what you are limited too but once root and a Recovery Shell, you don't need to use PC36IMG and I would recommend staying clear of them.
Also, if you install a Rom with the PC36IMG wrapper, rename or delete it after a succesful flash, lest you will experience a significant delay while the zip file is being interrogate upon all subsequent reboots (and it is all to easy to accidentally reflash that Rom- ugh!)

THis is not to say that there is no use for PC36IMG. There is and I post them from time to time though I have stopped posting them by that name. I instruct the user to rename them to PC36IMG. That way they know what they are installing and understand the process. And if they have a working recovery shell, they don't need to use the HBoot automated install system.