PPCGeeks

PPCGeeks (http://forum.ppcgeeks.com/index.php)
-   CDMA TP Development (http://forum.ppcgeeks.com/forumdisplay.php?f=68)
-   -   WM 6.5 Is it worth it? (http://forum.ppcgeeks.com/showthread.php?t=64317)

redd214 04-09-2009 05:40 PM

Re: WM 6.5 Is it worth it?
 
for some its worth it for others its not, just like tf3d some hate it some love it. only was to find out if its for you is to try it.

Hafrust 04-09-2009 05:42 PM

Re: WM 6.5 Is it worth it?
 
Don't forget, 6.5 is still beta, so it will only continue to improve.

bjhill2112 04-09-2009 05:46 PM

Re: WM 6.5 Is it worth it?
 
Sorry, but I've got to rant just a little here.

I've seen that a ton of people who have never flashed a 6.5 ROM trying out Juicy/MM's Copper project. For most of them I think it's probably a mistake. 6.5 is still beta (actually probably alpha!) - we don't have an official RC from Microsoft afaik. Copper is stripped down to it's bones on purpose. The idea is to start benchmarking and seeing how it all works, see what needs to be added and what doesn't, etc.

As for all the customizing - it will happen eventually. You can't seriously expect it to be all nice and easy before the OS has even been release do you? TBH - a lot of the effort people are spending on trying to figure out how Titanium works may be a little bit wasted. MS has already announced that they are going to release a new version of their old Theme Customizer. I'm sure that documentation for Titanium will be released at some point. Eventually we'll see all sorts of cool widgets being built. For now though, we just need to be patient. And if you want all the functionality of TF3d, then by all means use TF3d. It runs great on 6.5 - smooth as butter!

dan-htc-touch 04-09-2009 05:53 PM

Re: WM 6.5 Is it worth it?
 
well said

Hafrust 04-09-2009 05:56 PM

Re: WM 6.5 Is it worth it?
 
Agreed...very well said. But, I still enjoy tinkering with Titanium and playing around with different modifications to it, even if they may be short lived.

pidge 04-09-2009 06:12 PM

Re: WM 6.5 Is it worth it?
 
OK, i've read the last 5 pages and I've seen the subjects of speed and UI come up several times but no mention of battery life. Has that improve any?

bjhill2112 04-09-2009 07:33 PM

Re: WM 6.5 Is it worth it?
 
1 Attachment(s)
Quote:

Originally Posted by Hafrust (Post 837016)
Agreed...very well said. But, I still enjoy tinkering with Titanium and playing around with different modifications to it, even if they may be short lived.

Absolutely! Playing around with new stuff is hellafun... that's why I'm a developer IRL - lol :headbang:

My rant was just because I was seen a ton of people complaining about how sparse 6.5 is and wanting to know why the panels don't do stuff they want it to, etc.

Quote:

Originally Posted by pidge (Post 837065)
OK, i've read the last 5 pages and I've seen the subjects of speed and UI come up several times but no mention of battery life. Has that improve any?

I started up the battery logger just a little bit ago and left my phone to sit. I have it set to automatically receive emails from exchange at work and checks my gmail every 30 min. I also have the Titanium Weather app checking the weather every 30 min. I'm using the 1.11 radio.

Here's a copy of the log. I have nothing to compare it to though...

nanoware 04-09-2009 09:04 PM

Re: WM 6.5 Is it worth it?
 
ummmm..... im never going back to 6.1......

6.5 just keeps getting better and better.

6.1 is not really finger friendly

6.5 is. i can actually scroll through my text messages, contacts, programs menu correctly

gotta love kinetic scrolling =) - that's the #1 reason why I'm on 6.5 for good

kevm14 04-09-2009 09:38 PM

Re: WM 6.5 Is it worth it?
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by nanoware (Post 837407)
ummmm..... im never going back to 6.1......

6.5 just keeps getting better and better.

6.1 is not really finger friendly

6.5 is. i can actually scroll through my text messages, contacts, programs menu correctly

gotta love kinetic scrolling =) - that's the #1 reason why I'm on 6.5 for good

Thank you for this valuable input. Why is this not important to some people? I hate the stylus! Someone was talking about usability earlier in this thread. Well, there it is.

ace741 04-10-2009 12:40 AM

Re: WM 6.5 Is it worth it?
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by nanoware (Post 837407)
ummmm..... im never going back to 6.1......

6.5 just keeps getting better and better.

6.1 is not really finger friendly

6.5 is. i can actually scroll through my text messages, contacts, programs menu correctly

gotta love kinetic scrolling =) - that's the #1 reason why I'm on 6.5 for good

I'm a bit confused. I thought I already had kinetic scrolling on 6.1? Like flicking up and down your contacts right?

Don't want to sound like a hater, but running Mightymike's 4.16 I hardly ever pull out the stylus or click on the wrong things. 6.1 base is probably not finger friendly, but with all the enhancements it has received (rhodium) it is plenty finger friendly to me. And no I don't have little fingers.

robotphood 04-10-2009 01:07 AM

Re: WM 6.5 Is it worth it?
 
With kinetic scrolling the scroll speed and distance depends on the force/speed you flick the screen. TF3D menus (like the programs menu) does this although not as smooth as it could be.

Asphyx 04-10-2009 01:13 AM

Re: WM 6.5 Is it worth it?
 
Well I have to laugh because most people who say it is blazing fast are the same ones who said 6.1 was blazing fast when it was a Spec Rom...

Guys before you say how fast you think it is try loading it up with the same amount of crap you had installed in your 6.1 ROM...

What you have to realize is the ROMs your running are blazing fast because most are CLEAN ROMS with minimal apps installed!

Any OS is going to be blazing fast under those conditions.

And racing to crash is not really all that important to me...

I want stability...thats why I have been running Mighty's roms on my TP.
I'm sure he will get his colab with Juicy stable at some point too...

Some guys talk about the stone ages but what they do is live in OS infancy...

Add all the time you have to wait after a reset of a buggy OS and you'll find all that speed isn't so fast when you want to do something...

It will be a great OS once the genius' on this site and XDA remove all of MS's mistakes from it....

But stop telling people they are stupid or should run 5.0 just because they don't have your flash and reset fetish!

Some of us actually need to USE the phone on occassion!

6.5 will be good once it's finished...
It's ain't finished yet!
I am hoping between Mighty and Juicy putting their heads together they will actually make it useable without having to flash every week and reset every second!

dan-htc-touch 04-10-2009 01:25 AM

Re: WM 6.5 Is it worth it?
 
I copied and pasted my oem selections from my 6.1 setup to 6.5 setup, and it's faster, same **** in rom, but most of the talk of speed regarding 21500 is that it's faster than all the other 6.5 sys's released to date

ace741 04-10-2009 01:34 AM

Re: WM 6.5 Is it worth it?
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by robotphood (Post 837937)
With kinetic scrolling the scroll speed and distance depends on the force/speed you flick the screen. TF3D menus (like the programs menu) does this although not as smooth as it could be.

So your saying that kinetic scrolling exist in both 6.1 and 6.5 but 6.5 is smoother and more accurate?

mlin 04-10-2009 01:36 AM

Re: WM 6.5 Is it worth it?
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by dan-htc-touch (Post 836694)
not mad... just go through the same thing every release, same when 6.1 came out everyone asked if it was worth it, now you can't find a 6.0 rom, worth it or not... it's innevitable, might as well start getting used to it.

Titanium plugin is cool, lots of potential for customization, all xml controlled, same with the startmenu, here is what I've done to start icons, love the way things look now
http://i335.photobucket.com/albums/m.../startmenu.jpg

i like your icons. mind sharing?

Asphyx 04-10-2009 01:52 AM

Re: WM 6.5 Is it worth it?
 
I know Dan..it probably is a bit faster right now...Hell it better be! LOL

Sorry for the rant I just saw one poster I decided wasn't worth quoting tell someone to go run 5.0 and I just think that is a poor attitude to take on a legitimate subject...

Most paid upwards of $300-400 for their phone and it should be used as more than just something you flash the latest rom into...
I got a guy I work with who saw my flashed TP and he has been trying to outdo me every week...

The other day he tried to show me a 6.5 flash he put on and tried to show me how cool he was...
He missed 3 calls due to lockup and had to reset three times trying to show me how COOL 6.5 is...LOL

I just have to laugh at that!

I will run 6.5 when it's done and with MM and J working together that day may be much sooner than I thought...

But there are so many people who are noobs, don't know who come to this site for advice...
And yahoos who simply flash whatever rom came out last so he can say he has the latest are the same guys who convince people to brick and or makew their phone un-usable!

To me it is simply not an upgrade until it works better than what I have in EVERY way....

6.5 just isn't there yet....but with Copper I have hopes it soon will be.
And fully TF3D2 compatible...
If TF Detacher or second today works on it then I will have my cake and eat it too! LOL

Ihave faith in Mike and Juicy to get me there...
I know mike is as much a stickler for stability as I am!

dan-htc-touch 04-10-2009 02:05 AM

Re: WM 6.5 Is it worth it?
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by mlin (Post 837974)
i like your icons. mind sharing?

no problem, need to also use something to move icons, or edit the rgu, it uses a dummy prov to replace the one in sys, because I'm lazy and don't like editing provs

http://dan-vogue-titan.ppckitchen.org/6.5%20icons.rar

robotphood 04-10-2009 03:29 AM

Re: WM 6.5 Is it worth it?
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by ace741 (Post 837972)
So your saying that kinetic scrolling exist in both 6.1 and 6.5 but 6.5 is smoother and more accurate?

No, only in the TF3D menus. ie; programs list. 6.5 has system wide kinetic scrolling. 6.1 only has 2(?) speeds? Slow and flick to the bottom/top.

itouch24 04-10-2009 09:28 AM

Re: WM 6.5 Is it worth it?
 
there is no weather tabbar on the new 6.5 interface...?

MiltonPro 04-10-2009 09:58 AM

Re: WM 6.5 Is it worth it?
 
Copper ROM is great for what it is, Just a beta. Yes, created by 2 of the most popular chefs around. But lets be honest. Alot of us are having more issues than we like to mention, out of respect I guess.

There isn't a many reliable cabs out for 6.5 yet, its all Trial and Error right now.

With that said.... Its obviously the direction Microsoft is going in....Its like transitioning from XP to Vista... Ugly at first, now its dependible but still waiting for windows7 to close the deal.

So the way I see it.... YOu can either join the fun. Install Copper0.0.0.1 and learn along with everyone on tweaks and configurations....

Or sit back for a few months and wait till the more complete and stable ROMS are fully cooked.

For myself. I am gonna get as much experience with wm 6.5 as I can. Trying to keep the pace....

Hafrust 04-10-2009 10:04 AM

Re: WM 6.5 Is it worth it?
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by itouch24 (Post 838389)
there is no weather tabbar on the new 6.5 interface...?

Not by default, but you can add it in.

SyXbiT 04-10-2009 11:39 AM

Re: WM 6.5 Is it worth it?
 
i would say no
just flashed to copper, and did the new rhodium tf3d from xda.
i do like the added features to tf3d, but WM6.5 is a joke. it's yet another TINY improvement. seriously, they changed a menu, ???
that's basically it
6.5 is like 6.1, which was just 6.0 with threaded text messages
and 6.0 was basically 5.0
all because they can't finish up windows mobile 7.

the 'new' features are probably not worth the bugs, lag, alpha status just yet

mpeters13 04-10-2009 11:44 AM

Re: WM 6.5 Is it worth it?
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by ace741 (Post 836558)
I went from MightyMike's 4.16 to Copper . 6.5 is new and flashy, but I'm having hard time convincing myself that is WAY much better. People say its blazing fast and such, but IMO, MightyMike' 4.16 ROM is fast as well. Considering the daily activities I use my phone for, 6.5 didn't really offer much to make usability easier. Its actually harder cause you have to get used to its differences and find ways to do things quicker like you did in the previous ROM you were using.

I have not been able to find out a way to configure my TF3D on 6.5 ( I tried Starmans too) the way I had it on 6.1 . The Diamond TF3D Config did not work on Starman's ROM. One area I do notice 6.5 is faster on is clicking on Start, Settings. But in all honesty, how many times a week would I be accessing my Settings menu? Whatever settings I change are accessible from TF3D (Turning On and OFF bluetooth and WI-FI) . If anyone else would like to point out what is faster in 6.5 than 6.1 please do so. Without pulling out my nanosecond stop watch, I do not see a huge speed increase in 6.5

I'm glad I'm not the only one finding this sluggish. Yes, chrome is exciting because it's new, but it isn't really amazing. Personally, I think it could use a configuration tool.

People state that it's blazing fast, but I've experienced sluggishness and lockups while performing simple tasks. I went ahead and flipped up the caches and it helped a bit. (Yeah... I realize it's a BETA.) I'm having a more difficult time pressing OK in this version for some reason. The new Internet Explorer is extremely buggy/laggy, but if I can throw an older version on, I think I'll be set. Opera seems to run fine though, but I really want to take advantage of Chrome's IE menu. It's convenient.

Microsoft really oughta reconsider having Chrome's Music menu play all songs, and simply launch Windows Media Player instead. The larger the MP3 library, the harder it chunks.

I REALLY LOVE the new lock feature. It's brilliant!

I'll probably use it for another week and run back to MightyROM 4.16, unless I can get TouchFlo3D working.

hibby50 04-10-2009 11:45 AM

Re: WM 6.5 Is it worth it?
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by TurboFool (Post 836004)
Personally, yes, I think it was worth it. Despite having typical bugginess of a beta ROM, I haven't been able to switch back to, say, MightyROM 4.16 because I don't want to walk away from the 6.5 stuff. I love the new Today screen (some people don't), finding it notably preferable to TouchFLO3D (both versions), and the finger-scrolling is 10X better. There are minor other things, and I'm about to flash to a newer one which has other improvements.

That said, it is a personal preference. If you like an ultra-stable phone, stick to a 6.1 build for now. 6.5 is surprisingly stable, almost Windows 7-level of surprising for a pre-release, but it still has minor issues that the released versions don't. Also don't switch if you're not up for flashing every few days. I used to do that back in the Titan days, and I got used to it, so it's not that big a deal. You'd be surprised how quickly you get used to bare essentials and figure out how infrequently you use certain apps which you can always just install when you need them. Or you use something like Sushimi to auto-configure your favorite settings for you.

Anyway, I give it a thumbs-up and don't want to go back. Your mileage may vary.

Very true, I run windows 7 and wm6.5 as my main OSes

kevm14 04-10-2009 12:07 PM

Re: WM 6.5 Is it worth it?
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by ace741 (Post 837972)
So your saying that kinetic scrolling exist in both 6.1 and 6.5 but 6.5 is smoother and more accurate?

6.1 doesn't appear to have ANY sort of native kinetic scrolling support. Everything that I've seen appears to be provided by TF3D. As soon as you get to a non-TF3D app, the scrolling is utterly terrible. No inertia, accidental clicks, accidental text selection. It's just bad.

MoonZ*BabysH 04-10-2009 12:11 PM

Re: WM 6.5 Is it worth it?
 
With Juicy and Mighty's Collabo, Copper, i dont see myself goin back to 6.1. its so intuitve and fast. not to mention a fresh look.

gimme5 04-10-2009 12:20 PM

Re: WM 6.5 Is it worth it?
 
I personally prefer 6.1

6.5 looks way better, that's for sure, it's more finger friendly, the scrolling is so much smoother than 6.1. I don't care that much about those things, to be honest.

I have two little issues with 6.5:
1. lack of MRU (I use that a lot on 6.1, I miss it on 6.5)
2. you go deep in the settings menu, change one setting, and you're on the home page. If you need to change some other setting, you gotta do the whole navigation again.

To me, it's the form Vs function debate. I find 6.1 better suited for my needs right now. But 6.5 sure is pretty.

P.S. I haven't tried copper specifically

dan-htc-touch 04-10-2009 12:33 PM

Re: WM 6.5 Is it worth it?
 
I find titanium to be alot faster and easier to navigate then manila, I always hated manilla, it's a retarded peice of software

MightyMike 04-10-2009 12:37 PM

Re: WM 6.5 Is it worth it?
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by dan-htc-touch (Post 838782)
I find titanium to be alot faster and easier to navigate then manila, I always hated manilla, it's a retarded peice of software

I am the opposite until now.

I loved manila, wouldn't use any other todayscreen plugin. Until titanium came out :)

I absolutely LOVE IT.

I am still contemplating whether to include manila on MightyROM5.... I think it might get left out :D

kevm14 04-10-2009 12:40 PM

Re: WM 6.5 Is it worth it?
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by gimme5 (Post 838727)
2. you go deep in the settings menu, change one setting, and you're on the home page. If you need to change some other setting, you gotta do the whole navigation again.

Wow that sounds really iPhony. But unlike the iPhone, I assume that is customizable, so I'm not that worried. There's probably some registry key entitled "Enable return to home after settings update [0 or 1]."

MoonZ*BabysH 04-10-2009 12:52 PM

Re: WM 6.5 Is it worth it?
 
probly and if not gove it a lil time and im sure a Dev here or at XDA will figure it out. we just gotta wait.

Deimoss 04-10-2009 01:27 PM

Re: WM 6.5 Is it worth it?
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by kevm14 (Post 838806)
Wow that sounds really iPhony. But unlike the iPhone, I assume that is customizable, so I'm not that worried. There's probably some registry key entitled "Enable return to home after settings update [0 or 1]."

let me know when you find the registry key :evil4:

ace741 04-10-2009 02:23 PM

Re: WM 6.5 Is it worth it?
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by mightymike (Post 838793)
I am the opposite until now.

I loved manila, wouldn't use any other todayscreen plugin. Until titanium came out :)

I absolutely LOVE IT.

I am still contemplating whether to include manila on MightyROM5.... I think it might get left out :D

Noooooooooooooo say it isn't so. I like Manila. Just to make sure I understand what we are talking about, the term Manila is used interchangably with TF3D right?

I haven't used Titanium. But is it is, does it provide the quick access to the same things as TF3D does without crowding your home screen? Looking at the different forums on how to cuztomize 6.5 makes my head spin. Don't think I have a handle on all the lingo being thrown around either.

redd214 04-10-2009 02:29 PM

Re: WM 6.5 Is it worth it?
 
yes manila = touch flo 3d. Titanium is the plugin in the copper rom. flash and see how you like it. im with mike on this one. i have always been a huge manila fan, its one of the reasons i got the phone, but this rom in particular is makin me rethink it!

Hafrust 04-10-2009 02:33 PM

Re: WM 6.5 Is it worth it?
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by redd214 (Post 839096)
Titanium is the plugin in the copper rom.

Just to clarify, it's not limited to the copper rom. It's the default today plug-in for 6.5 in general.

bjhill2112 04-10-2009 02:38 PM

Re: WM 6.5 Is it worth it?
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by ace741 (Post 839074)
Noooooooooooooo say it isn't so. I like Manila. Just to make sure I understand what we are talking about, the term Manila is used interchangably with TF3D right?

I haven't used Titanium. But is it is, does it provide the quick access to the same things as TF3D does without crowding your home screen? Looking at the different forums on how to cuztomize 6.5 makes my head spin. Don't think I have a handle on all the lingo being thrown around either.

Titanium is an enhanced version of Chrome which is the Smartphone (non-touch screen Windows Mobile) Today plug-in. Much of the customization of the UI can be done with simply editing the .crp files - which are just XML. They are also named very appropriately (ie LS_LockScene_480_640.cpr defines what your lock screen looks like in portrait if you have a VGA phone). Making new panels (think Tabs from TF3d) is a little more challenging, but mostly because not much has been developed specifically for Titanium, and the stuff that was done for Chrome just doesn't quite get you there. I have no doubt though that development for Titanium will be much easier than it is for TF3d/manila.

You may have also heard the term "Widgets". These have nothing to do with Titanium or the Today screen. These are special types of HTML files that WM 6.5 can use the new PIE infrastructure to display.

kevm14 04-10-2009 03:21 PM

Re: WM 6.5 Is it worth it?
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Deimoss (Post 838914)
let me know when you find the registry key :evil4:

Well the key isn't going to be named that. That's how it would appear in an Advanced Config-like utility, though. And I didn't say I was going to look for it, just that I wasn't worried. 6.5 isn't out yet.

ace741 04-10-2009 03:27 PM

Re: WM 6.5 Is it worth it?
 
Does Titanium allow you to customize the home screen to access the same amount of info as TF3D? Like preview text message, settings menu?

Hafrust 04-10-2009 03:33 PM

Re: WM 6.5 Is it worth it?
 
It doesn't preview messages, and by default it does not have a settings panel, but you can add one.

shach84 04-10-2009 03:39 PM

Re: WM 6.5 Is it worth it?
 
I downloaded copper this morning, now I realize how much I love TF3D... I'm currently going back to KK's.


All times are GMT -4. The time now is 05:52 AM.

Powered by vBulletin® ©2000 - 2025, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.
©2012 - PPCGeeks.com


Content Relevant URLs by vBSEO 3.6.0