Quote:
Originally Posted by divxrippimp
Will anyone else add some reviews? Ill organize them and make a scoring system...
I have a bunch of reviews i still have to post... and i gotta update the list to the new versions of some roms and rom info...
|
IMHO you can not post a reliable review after 24 hours of using a rom. I would think something more like 5-7 days is needed. I would also break the reviews/ratings on similar features sample:
0- Speed--vs-- Reliability
1--WM version 6.1 - versus - 6.5
2--Plain- versus Light apps- versus lots of Apps
3--Manila Version ( TF3d2, Tf3d, HD, Xmod, etc) - Versus Mobile Shell - Versus other today shells (Note that programs like Htc weather master or showaco allow u to modify manila more and the chef might omit them to make the rom faster , i think they should NOT be penalize for that)
4--Eye Candy ( custom icons vs defaults, wallpapers, themes)
5--Ability to customize - some roms pretty much dont have the complete netcf3.5 and installs fail or cause problems when You try to add CABS you like....
6-- How often the author releases fixes, updates apps etc.. Mighty rom, Juicy rom, Silence and other get a ton of updates and make it more tempting ..
I think its great you took the time to test them, believe me a lot of us still looking for the perfect rom. But you can NOT treat every rom the same. I for one loved the stock option of tf3d2 on CFAYs rom and put up with tf3d2's many flows until i decided to give mobile shell a try.... havent looked back.. lol
Again this is just a friendly critic about your critic...