Really sorry to hear that.
You could try the case from seidio online (i think there's a holster you could buy for it if you're into that sorta thing):
http://www.seidioonline.com/ProductD...e=CSR2HTCH2-BK
and you really should use a full body screen protector like these:
http://www.bodyguardz.com/Sprint_Tou...nttouchpro.htm
http://www.ghost-armor.com/htc/htc-t.../prod_153.html
http://www.zagg.com/invisibleshield/...ns-shields.php
Those would have prevented your phone from getting all scratched up when it fell out... There are other brands too, but those are the most used i think (all have a lifetime warranty).
Look for videos on youtube of these skins, one guy slides it across the pavement and it survives... others scratch it with a key to show how well it holds up.
Good hunting.