Ok apparently when I added the contact to my blacklist, I pulled the entry directly out of my contacts list. I browsed to it and selected it. But it also has an option to select "last call" and choose the an entry from the call logs. This makes a difference because the way the call log formats the info to your black list, and the way the contact list formats the info to your black list are different. It only seems to recognize it if its in the format pulled out of the call log, rather than the contacts list.
Contact list format example: 1234567890 (First Last)
Call Log format: (123) 456-7890 (Last, First)
|