[Zyphlin]

Originally Posted by htcphone

Sorry if you feel bad for my comment. I just wanted to give everyone a heads up on downloading such a bad cube. I did not call you names or threatened you in anyway... I just wanted to express my deep thoughts on truly how horrible this is. Nothing more.

Sweet mother mary of jesus. Thanks for "Giving everyone a heads up". I am sure your one line post about "how horrible it is", with no explanation, and no mention of exactly what other cubes people used, will completely negate the HUGE amount of praise this has got from the vast majority of posters here.

Sorry, I hope you don't mind critisim. I'm just expressing my deep thoughts of truly how horrible your post is.

1: I dought I am in the minority with my feelings. All you have to do is install this cube and you will understand my thoughts.

indeed. I am just the hundreds of positive posts throughout 7 pages worth of this thread are all a minority. There's really thousands of people hiding behind their keyboards thinking "grrr this suxxor".

2: No name calling. I am not a jackass, and I have enough friends to be happy. And just so you know, I write C++ so I understand how much time and effort it takes to make a piece of software like this. I find it futile in his effort for continuing such a terrible cube. Here... I will help you out Musicman... Trash the whole project and start all over again with a better layout. I'm not being rude.. just honest. If you don't adapt, you will never succeed.

Hi, I post on message boards, so I understand how much time and effort it is to make a post like this. I find it quite futile in your effort for continuing such horrible posting. Here...I will help you out htcphone...trash all your posts here, and your brain, and start over. I'm not being rude...just honest. If you don't attempt to understand reality, you will never succeed.

Well the stock cube is nice.. but theres better out there. I tried all of them and I truly must say this Mac cube falls flat on its face. First of all, nobody should get offended for a direct crtic like myself. You should consider you unsatisfied users and take all the input and put out something better. No harm in that. Plus remember this is a forum board you you critic and put your thoughts in how much you like or dislike.

Nuff said. =D>

Which ones have you tried exactly? The "custom cubes" on PPC geeks thus far of any major note are:
VistaCube 1 and 2
iCube (created by Music and myself)
iFade (based off the cube created by music)
eyeCube (based off the cube created by music)
Minimal Cube (created by Music)
and this one.

There's also a few very interesting, and some very poor, animations over at XDA Forums that you may've tried as well. If you HONESTLY tried a lot of them, I assume you are being completely facetious when you say that Music's MacFlo is THE WORST, as there were some HORRID ones. Also note that the vast majority of custom cubes that have been out for a while and had more than the standard amount of icons on them likely also were derived from Music's hard work.

Yes, this is a forum. You can be critical of other peoples works. There have been a few people in here that were critical.

Know what they did different then you?

They said exactly what they disliked. They said "I dislike this cube and don't think its good because the icons are too small". Or "I dislike this cube because the contact screen doesn't fit right. Or "I dislike this cube because it moves to slow". THOSE are criticisms. Yours is not. Know why:

Critisim: "disapproval expressed by pointing out faults or shortcomings"

You poitned out no fault. You poitned out no shortcoming. You just said "This cube sucks". That's not helpful, not to people reading this, not to the developer, because it doesn't explain WHY it sucks other than you stating it and unless you happen to be god on high of PDA's, who words are absolute truth once spoken, just saying "it sucks" doesn't MEAN ANYTHING.

Originally Posted by Musicman247

As I stated before, I would love some input! So far, though, you have posted nothing but contempt for the skin without validating your opinion with specific thoughts. I look forward to reading your "programmers perspective"!

I want to say personally that even though I have stopped using the MacFlo as I like the larger icons and simpler atmosphere of the iCube in relation to it, that I thought it was great work and a very innovative concept, and thank you for the work on it.

Originally Posted by htcphone

Good luck with this terrible thing. I wont say no more. Looks like some ppl cant take no critic.

I won't say ANY more. Looks like PEOPLE can't take ANY CRITICISM.

And yes, they can. Music has taken a great deal of it in this thread. Yours, hwoever, wasn't criticism. It was just pure negativity.