the body glove s nice but like a lot of others, has issues with the front(top) of the case not fitting ver well or not fitting very well after small tab cracks . I have tried many and the one that seems to fit best, look best and have least problems is this one
http://cgi.ebay.com/Soft-Skin-Silico...item1c0f2e1733 this may be what you call the Blue Jay? It takes about 2 weeks shipping but is BY FAR the best one I have tried (tried many) and has not ripped yet and looks great in addition to being the only one I have seen that fits over the back allowing more of the speaker quality out. I have not tried invisashield and that might be the only other one close but that is more like a screen protector for the whole phone and not really a "case". This silicone case does not just snap on like the other cases but IMHO has a better way of fitting onto the case that allows it to stay on much easier and no tabs to crack off