[Noir]

I was wondering the same thing about the touch hd2 and the only motivation I had was doing the wp7s upgrade (which may or may not happen). But for the past 2 weeks I have been using the iphone (and save from keyboard, texting and facebook, its pretty awful) and I want to jump into a new phone experience. 4.3 in is big (that's what she said) but I also have to see the big deal...the largest thing that impressed me was the additions that htc added with pinch to zoom, screen sensitivity, development and hacking...and a myriad of other things.

I am already not without a keyboard phone so to speak (bad esn phone with a bad screen that works just cosmetically ugly touch pro 2) so I want to see what it is like with t mobile and buy the phone outright and save my upgrade for a wp7s device...

All in all I guess its in the eye of the beholder. I lusted after the touch hd2 for the processor and quality htc puts in their devices. but opinions vary especially after playing with it. Its up to you and no one will fault you for not getting it