I haven't had any issue with magic button itself, and when I use the don't show phone when inactive. I have no problem with icon. it doesn't pop up till I go to phone or hit the send button. and its the correct icon. I've voiced this opinion before and will again. I love magic button, and its the first thing I install. I have tried others, not the one malatesta suggested though, and find this the best because of the battery meter and it takes up no today screen space. I like my today screen clean as can be.

~mike