Why doesn't the one vogue charge the battery? What happens? Have you tried flashing it back to stock to se if that has any effect? If that does not work then you may have a hardware problem with the one that doesn't charge. If that is the case then I suggest you take the two devices and make one good phone. You could take all the better parts from both devices and put together one good one. Take a look at TMZ's Bring New Life To Your Vogue Thread. Good Luck!!