[phoenix316]

Just from touching a phone in a store does not really allow you to make a valid comparison.

The camera on the Incredible is much, much better than the Droid's, especially in low light.

I owned the Droid for 2 months and have owned the Incredible from launch date.

I gave my Droid to my wife cause she needed a new phone and I wanted the incredible.

The Incredible Pros:
Lighter
Faster (than no OCed Droid)
More social networking integration (I don't use it, but other people may find it useful)
Much better camera (especially in low light)
2.1 with Live Wallpapers out of the box
Sense has some cool features such as a lot of information at the lock screen
The HTC keyboard works great with multi touch in landscape mode
Better multi touch

Cons:
Not rooted yet (will be done soon, hopefully, but may not be able to run unsigned ROMS.
No keyboard (i never used the physical keyboard, so didn't matter to me)

The incredible will be a much better phone than the Droid if the community gets behind it, otherwise the Droid will always be a better phone.